by Josh

Why does audio sound bad, or need to be rendered, in Final Cut Pro, Avid, Premiere or iMovie?

April 28, 2008 in editing, post audio by Josh

Final Cut (and other editing apps) will accept many kinds and formats of audio for import into the Browser or Timeline.

However, just because they will, doesn’t mean you should! :)

If you import compressed audio, for example, in MP3 or AAC codecs, or audio in a different bit or sample rate than your Timeline (such as 44.1 KHz, 32 KHz or 12-bit), you will often hear clicks, pops, and audio dropouts while editing, which is distracting for your creative process, and in many cases your audio will require rendering before you can even hear it, which sounds like “beep-beep-beep-beep” and wastes a lot of your time.

Our solution is to batch convert all audio to 48KHz, uncompressed, stereo or mono for editing before importing.

We use DV Kitchen for this, it comes with a preset already designed for this.

If you’d like to batch convert audio files on Windows XP, click here!

by Josh

Why do all my clips need to be rendered before I can play them?

December 31, 2005 in editing by Josh

The red line at the top of the timeline indicates that the clip must be rendered before it will play back.

This could result from many things, such as having many intensive filters applied to the clip and being in “Safe” RT Mode.

But for novices, nine times out of ten, the reason the clip “redlines” is because the sequence settings do not match the footage type you are dropping into it.

Check the clip format by highlighting it and pressing Cmd 9.

Check the sequence format by clicking in an empty area of the timeline, then pressing Cmd 0 (zero).

The two should match, meaning frame size, frame rate, video and audio format should be identical.

If they don’t match you have two choices:

1. Transcode your incoming media to the format of your timeline, e.g., if your timeline is HDV 1080i 29.97 fps, with audio at 48 KHz, 16-bit uncompressed, then transcode all the video you want to edit on that timeline to that format. We always use DV Kitchen for batch transcoding, it’s fast and high quality. This is the best option.

2. If the video clip you want to use in your movie is already in an editing codec, like Pro Res, HDV, DV, DVCPRO, JPEG etc. then you can just import it in its native format and hope it plays in real time or close to it.